77
BASSI v. PATTEN
Cite as 592 F.Supp.2d 77 (D.D.C. 2009)
Damages
33. The effects of the outrageous conduct of North Korea will be felt by Massie,
Tuck, McClarren, and Rose Bucher for the
rest of their lives. Because § 1606 of the
FSIA provides that a ‘‘foreign state shall
be liable in the same manner and to the
same extent as a private individual under
like circumstances,’’ 28 U.S.C. § 1606,
plaintiffs are entitled to the typical array
of compensatory damages that may be
awarded against tortfeasors in California,
Virginia, Illinois and Pennsylvania.
(Pain and Suffering of Massie, Tuck,
McClarren, and Cdr. Bucher During
Captivity)
[13] 36. The pain and suffering endured by Massie, Tuck, McClarren, and
Cdr. Bucher, over the eleven months of
their captivity was extensive and shocking. While there is no set formula for
quantifying the damages for such pain
and suffering, in some cases of prolonged
and abusive captivity, plaintiffs are awarded approximately $10,000 per day for the
pain and suffering they experienced while
captive. See, e.g., Price v. Socialist People’s Libyan Arab Jamahiriya, 384
F.Supp.2d 120, 134 (D.D.C.2005) (‘‘Price
II’’).
[14] 37. Massie, Tuck, McClarren,
and Cdr. Bucher case are entitled to damages of $10,000 per day, for a total of
$3,350,000 each for the pain and suffering
they endured throughout their 335 days of
captivity. Rose Bucher is entitled to $1,
250, 000 for the pain and suffering she
suffered during this period.
(Pain and Suffering After Captivity)
[15] 38. As was recognized in Price
II ‘‘[i]n some cases the per diem amount
will adequately compensate plaintiffs for
pain and suffering both during and after
captivity.’’ Price II, 384 F.Supp.2d at 135.
As in Price, ‘‘this is not one of those
cases.’’ Id. In this case, Massie, Tuck,
McClarren, suffered physical and mental
harm that has endured for the past 39
years and likely will continue to endure
throughout the rest of their lives. Cdr.
Bucher suffered such effects until he died.
[16] 39. Massie, Tuck, McClarren,
each, is entitled to $13, 400,000 for their
post release and future pain and suffering.
The estate of Cdr. Bucher is entitled to
recover $11,000,000 for his post release
pain and suffering.
A judgment accompanies this memorandum.
,
Neill S. BASSI, Plaintiff,
v.
Jarrod M. PATTEN, et al., Defendants.
Civil Action No. 07–1277 (JDB).
United States District Court,
District of Columbia.
Jan. 8, 2009.
Background: Bar doorman who was allegedly injured in physical altercation with
patrons brought action against patrons for
assault, battery, and intentional infliction
of emotional distress. Parties filed motions
in limine to exclude evidence.
Holdings: The District Court, John D.
Bates, J., held that:
(1) evidence that doorman was contributorily negligent or assumed the risk of
his injuries by the nature of his employment was not admissible;