MASSIE v. GOVT. OF DEMOCRATIC PEOPLE’S OF KOREA
Cite as 592 F.Supp.2d 57 (D.D.C. 2008)
orders of officers, there were occasions
when enlisted North Korean men would
initiate beatings without the knowledge of
officers. See Ex. 15 at 155, ¶ 496.
59. The North Koreans used extreme
mental pressures to enforce the rules, such
as the ‘‘no talking’’ rule. While marching
back to his room, Massie asked the Pueblo’s Operations Officer whether he had
heard any news. This was overheard by
the guards. After Massie entered his
room, he was confronted by a particularly
large guard known as the Bear, who began
screaming at Massie while pointing his
AK–47 at Massie’s head. He then indicated that Massie was to open his mouth.
When Massie complied, the Bear stuck his
AK–47 into Massie’s mouth, ejected his
clip and flipped out a bullet to show that it
was loaded. He reinserted the clip and
then put his finger into the trigger guard
while he continued to scream at Massie.
Finally, he pulled the gun out of Massie’s
mouth and hit Massie with it causing Massie to fall over a bunk and onto the floor.
See Tr. 81, April 21, 2008.
60. On another occasion, Massie was
beaten unconscious because he refused to
sign a document that the North Koreans
wanted to send to his family. The beatings, which included Massie being kicked
in the stomach, back and groin, were followed by the threat that he would be shot.
See id. at 82.
61. Throughout the time the crew was
held hostage, North Korea engaged in a
prolonged effort to extract a public apology from the United States Government for
the Pueblo’s alleged intrusion into North
Korea’s territorial waters and for spying
on North Korea. As part of this effort,
the hostages were forced to participate in
staged press conferences held on August
13 and September 12, 1968. See Tr. 56,
April 22, 2008.; Ex. 15 at 155, ¶ 490.
67
62. The latter press conference was an
international press conference. At both
sessions, the Pueblo’s crew inserted innuendos and archaic and corny language into
their prepared statements to discredit the
propaganda. See Tr. 57–58, April 22, 2008.
63. In addition, the North Koreans
pressured the hostages to write false letters home to family, friends, and members
of Congress reporting that they were receiving humane treatment and asking that
the United States apologize for the spying
and intrusions into North Korean waters.
See Ex. 15 at 153, ¶ 477; Id. at 157,
¶¶ 506–509. Hostages who resisted were
severely beaten until they complied. See
Ex. 15 at 157, ¶ 506.
64. The Pueblo’s crew also was subjected to North Korean propaganda films. In
June 1968, two short subjects were shown
in which it became apparent that the
North Koreans did not know what the
middle finger gesture meant. This knowledge became an integral part of the crew’s
anti-propaganda campaign, which caused
the crew to feel that they had achieved a
victory, albeit a small one, by spoiling the
North Korean’s propaganda by humiliating
them on a world stage. See Tr. 42, 106–07,
April 21, 2008.
65. When asked what the finger meant,
the crew deceived the North Koreans by
explaining that it was the ‘‘Hawaiian Good
Luck Sign.’’ This would later result in two
weeks of severe beatings and torture of
every hostage in early December. See Tr.
58, April 22, 2008.
66. The October 18 issue of Time Magazine exposed the true meaning of the
‘‘Hawaiian Good Luck Sign.’’ In late November or early December, the North Korean captors learned that the middle finger gesture, which had been shown in
many pictures and videos, was an obscene
gesture. See Tr. 107, April 21, 2008; Tr.
58, April 22, 2008.